There is a whole lot to like about the Colonel jacket from SupFen, and even more to like about it when you choose to order from SoCal Swords. I got the package next day (!!! like, whaaat?! I'm in SoCal too but they beat Amazon dude it's wild!) and ordering was simple, price was right, and I get to support a small US business who is doing it right. Thanks guys
As indicated this is my first HEMA jacket and I am a military saber/broadsword fencer (almost) exclusively so my needs and priorities may not align perfectly with the 'typical' HEMA practitioner. That said I wanted a jacket that would fit well and cover me properly while looking interesting (and IMO this jacket is a nicer design than Spes's Officer but that's me) and not weigh a ton. I didn't have a lot of empirical evidence available, nor much to compare to between other jackets, but I am very pleased with what I got. The jacket itself is beefier than I expected with more padding built in than I'd have guessed. It is a hot jacket certainly, but likely not as hot as other 'heavy' options in the market. I wager the 800N (read 'redundant layers of fabric') provides more insulation and heat retention than a lighter coat. That said, I think this model is a good balance. I feel very safe using synthetics in this jacket, to the point where I believe I won't need to up-armor for steel saber/broadsword/spadroon (a la additional external plates etc). Ultimately we'll find out, quite soon in fact
The overall quality of the coat is great, as is the hardware. All the stitching is expertly finished, the interior and guts of the coat are nicely done and easy to work with (removing pads etc), the zipper feels very high quality (as good as if not better than all my YKK motorcycle jackets), and the actual fit feels bang on per size chart. I'm on the upper end of size L (chest/gut/height) and the L fits well. I can get in and out without issue, the arms move freely and easily, sleeve length and torso length are bang on...the only fit issue I have pertains to my collar style gorget and the fitment of the neck closure. It all fits, but it is more snug than I'm used to. I imagine that with more time and wear (and adjustment from me) it is a temporary detractor. If it continues to be a problem luckily a minor alteration is something I can figure out at home cheaply and effectively
The Colonel fits my needs perfectly while remaining an affordable piece of kit. I expect to use it for years to come and am eager to try more Superior Fencing products through SoCal Swords. If you like the look of the coat I recommend it fully. You're buying good protection and a very well finished product at a very fair price. It could be a little lighter, it could breath a little better, I think that could be said of any fencing jacket that is able to stand up to the heavy blows this one can. I also have to state plainly that I'm VERY heat sensitive, having lived at altitude for a long time anything over 70F outside makes me sweaty anyway so it is possible your perception of the heat and insulation will vary. That all said though, I'm happy to wear it in my fencing and wouldn't doubt it for a second if I were practicing longsword aggressively as well as my chosen focus of single handed late-period swords